Untermensch (; plural: Untermenschen) is a German language word literally meaning 'underman', 'sub-man', or '', which was extensively used by Germany's Nazi Party to refer to their opponents and non-Aryan race people they deemed as inferior. It was mainly used against "the masses from the East", that is Jews, Romani people, and Slavs (mainly ethnic Polish people, Belarusians, Czech people, Ukrainians, Russians and Serbs).
The term was also applied to " Mischling" (persons of mixed race "Aryan" and non-Aryan ancestry) and black people.
The German word Untermensch had been used in earlier periods, but it had not been used in a racial sense, for example, it was used in the 1899 novel Der Stechlin by Theodor Fontane. Since most writers who employed the term did not address the question of when and how the word entered the German language, into English, Untermensch is usually translated as "subhuman". The leading Nazi who attributed the concept of the Eastern Europe "under man" to Stoddard was Alfred Rosenberg who, referring to communists of the Soviet Russia, wrote in his Der Mythus des zwanzigsten Jahrhunderts (1930) that "this is the kind of human being that Lothrop Stoddard has called the 'under man.'" "...den It needs to be mentioned though that despite Nazi official support for The Myth of the Twentieth Century and Rosenberg's prominent role in promoting Nazi ideology Adolf Hitler declared that it was not to be considered official ideology of the Nazi PartyHitler, Adolf; Hugh Trevor-Roper. Adolf Hitler's Secret Conversations 1941-1944, p. 400. and he privately described the book as "mysticism" and "nonsense". Albert Speer claimed that Goebbels mocked Alfred Rosenberg.Albert Speer, Erinnerungen, Frankfurt am Main / Berlin / Wien 1969, p. 139 Goebbels also called the book a "philosophical belch".
It is possible that Stoddard constructed his "under man" as an opposite of Friedrich Nietzsche's Übermensch (superman) concept. Stoddard does not explicitly say this, but he critically refers to the "superman" idea at the end of his book (p. 262). Wordplays with Nietzsche's term seem to have been used repeatedly as early as the 19th century and, due to the German linguistic trait of being able to combine prefixes and roots almost at will in order to create new words, this development can be considered logical. For instance, German author Theodor Fontane contrasts the Übermensch/Untermensch word pair in chapter 33 of his novel Der Stechlin. Nietzsche used Untermensch at least once in contrast to Übermensch in Die fröhliche Wissenschaft (1882). Earlier examples of Untermensch include Romanticist Jean Paul using the term in his novel Hesperus (1795) in reference to an Orangutan (Chapter "8. Hundposttag").
The Nazi party and thereafter also the Nazi Germany repeatedly used the term Untermensch in writings and speeches which they directed against the Jews. In the pamphlet "The SS as an Anti-Bolshevist Fighting Organization", published in 1936, Himmler wrote:
In his speech " Weltgefahr des Bolschewismus" ("World danger of Bolshevism") in 1936, Joseph Goebbels said that "subhumans exist in every people as a leavening agent".Paul Meier-Benneckenstein, Deutsche Hochschule für Politik Titel: Dokumente der Deutschen Politik, Volume 4, Junker und Dünnhaupt Verlag, Berlin, 2. ed., 1937; speech held on 10 September 1936; In German: "... das Untermenschentum, das in jedem Volke als Hefe vorhanden ist ...". At the 1935 Nazi party congress rally at Nuremberg, Goebbels also declared that, “Bolshevism is the declaration of war by Jewish-led international subhumans against culture itself." Goebbels speech at the 1935 Nuremberg Rally
The most notorious example of the usage of the term Untermensch by the Nazis is a Schutzstaffel (SS) brochure entitled " ", distributed by the Reich Security Main Office under the directives of Heinrich Himmler.Sources:
Published in 1942 after the start of Operation Barbarossa, it is around 50 pages long and consists, for the most part, of photos portraying the natives of Eastern Europe in an extremely negative way. Nearly four million copies of the pamphlet were printed in the German language and distributed across German-occupied territories. The contents of the " Der Untermensch" brochure extensively emphasized Himmler's racist demonization of Russians as "bestial untermenschen" and Jews as "the decisive leader of untermenschen".Sources:
As the civil war approaches or takes place, there is a divergence in the meaning of subhuman, on the rebel side it acquires a racial/Eugenics meaning,Vinyes Ribas, Ricard. CONSTRUYENDO A CAÍN. Ayer, nº 44, 2001, p.p. 227-250FERNÁNDEZ, José Guillermo Fouce, et al. España y sus derechos humanos: una deuda. Revista Digital Universitaria. 01 de julio 2010 • Volumen 11 Número 7 • ISSN: 1067-6079GUZMÁN, Eduardo de, et al. El terror desde el poder. Tiempo de historia. Año VIII, n. 92-93 (1 jul. 1982), p. 32-45 beside ideologic,Fresán Cuenca, F. J. (1). Un ideólogo olvidado: el joven José Antonio Maravall y la defensa del Estado Nacionalsindicalista. Su colaboración en "Arriba", órgano oficial de FET y de las JONS. 1939-1941. Memoria Y Civilización, 6, 153-187. https://doi.org/10.15581/001.6.33779 while on the republican side it is more of a cultural type.
Once the war was won by the rebel side, Francoism, similar to Nazi Germany (and Soviet Russia as wellNikolay Ustryalov, From NEP to Soviet Socialism (1934) ( text online ) ), promoted the idea of creating a new man,Vinyes Ribas, Ricard. Las desapariciones infantiles durante el franquismo y sus consecuencias. International Journal of Iberian Studies, Volume 19, Issue 1, Aug 2006, p. 53 - 7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1386/ijis.19.1.53/1 which led to the brutal repression of the Spanish population. Gonzalo de Aguilera, the press officer for the Nationalist faction during the Spanish Civil War, made the following Classicide statements to journalist John T. Whitaker:
"We have to kill, kill, you know? They are like animals, you know, and we cannot expect them to get rid of the virus of Bolshevism. After all, rats and lice are the carriers of the plague. Now I hope you understand what we mean by the regeneration of Spain... Our programme consists... of exterminating one third of the male population of Spain. That would cleanse the country and get rid of the proletariat. And it is also economically convenient. There will be no more unemployment in Spain, do you understand?"
Rich, Norman (1974). Hitler's War Aims: the Establishment of the New Order, p. 276–277. W. W. Norton & Company Inc., New York.
as well as within occupied territories.Norman Davies. . Pp. 167, 209. The concept of the Slavs in particular being Untermenschen served the Nazis' political goals; it was used to justify their expansionist policy and especially their aggression against Poland and the Soviet Union in order to achieve Lebensraum, particularly in Ukraine. Early plans of the Nazi officials (summarized as Generalplan Ost) envisioned the ethnic cleansing and extermination of no fewer than 50 million people, who were not considered fit for Germanization, from territories it wanted to conquer in Europe. Nazi planners considered Ukraine's chernozem ("black earth") soil as a particularly desirable zone for colonization.
Prior to the launch of Operation Barbarossa, the Wehrmacht's High Command began issuing orders to enable German soldiers to indiscriminately target the inhabitants of Eastern Europe and unleash systematic violence against entire populations. German Army was instructed to grant carte blanche to the anti-Jewish massacres carried out by the Einsatzgruppen death squads in German-occupied territories. “Guidelines for the Conduct of the Troops in Russia” issued by the German High Command in 19 May 1941, ordered German troops to target Jews, partisans, Bolsheviks, etc. and described the war in Eastern Europe as a "historic task to liberate the German people once forever from the Asiatic-Jewish danger". In 1943 Himmler issued a secret order for the destruction of the Warsaw Ghetto in order to eliminate the "living space" of 500,000 Untermenschen, unsuitable for the Germans. Orders to Friedrich Krueger for the destruction of the Warsaw ghetto, a photocopy at the Harvard Law School Library Nuremberg Trials Project Deux documents allemands touchant la destruction du ghetto de Varsovie, sourced to Le Monde, Juif 1950/4 (N° 30), page 16; includes a low-resolution photocopy of the original Himmler's orderJosef Wulf, "Vom Leben. Kampf und Tod im Ghetto Warsau", April 16, 1958, p. 176
Historian Robert Jan van Pelt writes that for the Nazis, "it was only a small step to a rhetoric pitting the European Mensch against the Soviet Untermensch, which had come to mean a Russian in the clutches of Judeo-Bolshevism."
The Untermensch concept included Jews, Roma and Sinti (Gypsies), and Slavic peoples such as Poles, Ukrainians, and Russians. Slavs were regarded as Untermenschen, barely fit for exploitation as slaves. Hitler and Goebbels compared them to the "rabbit family" or to "stolid animals" that were "idle" and "disorganized" and spread like a "wave of filth". Sealing Their Fate (Large Print 16pt) by David Downing, page 49 However, some among the Slavs who happened to have Nordic race racial features were deemed to have distant Germanic descent which meant partially "Aryan" origin, and if under 10 years old, they were to be Germanisation (see: kidnapping of children by Nazi Germany).
The Nazis were utterly contemptuous of the Slavs, as even prior to World War II, Slavs – particularly the Poles – were deemed to be inferior to Germans and other Aryans. After Adolf Hitler gained political power in Germany, the concept of non-Aryan "sub-human slave-material" was developed and started to be used also towards other Slavic peoples.Timm, Annette F. (2010) The Politics of Fertility in Twentieth-Century Berlin. London: Cambridge University Press. p. 188 Polish people were at the bottom of the Slavic "racial hierarchy" established by the Nazis. Soon after the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact expired, Russians also started to be seen as "subhumans". Similarly, Belarusians, Czechs, Slovaks, and Ukrainians were considered to be inferior. Nonetheless, there were Slavs such as Bosniaks, Bulgarians, and Croats who collaborated with Nazi Germany that were still being perceived as not racially "pure" enough to reach the status of Germanic peoples, yet they were eventually considered ethnically better than other Slavs, mostly due to theories about these nations having a minimal amount of Slavic genes and considerable admixtures of Germanic and Turkic blood.Shirer, William L. (1960) The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. New York: Simon and Schuster. pp.937, 939. Quotes: "The Jews and the Slavic people were the Untermenschen – subhumans." (937); "The obsession of the Germans with the idea that they were the master race and that Slavic people must be their slaves was especially virulent in regard to Russia. Erich Koch, the roughneck Reich Commissar for the Ukraine, expressed it in a speech at Kiev on 5 March 1943.We are the Master Race and must govern hard but just ... I will draw the very last out of this country. I did not come to spread bliss ... The population must work, work, and work again ... We are a master race, which must remember that the lowliest German worker is racially and biologically a thousand times more valuable than the population of. (emphasis added)
In order to forge a strategic alliance with the Independent State of Croatia – a puppet state created after the invasion of Yugoslavia and the Kingdom of Bulgaria, the Nazis deviated from a strict interpretation of their racial ideology, and Croats were officially described as "more Germanic than Slav", a notion supported by Croatia's fascist (Ustashe) dictator Ante Pavelić who maintained that the "Croats were descendants of the ancient Goths" and "had the Pan-Slavism forced upon them as something artificial".Rich, Norman (1974) Hitler's War Aims: the Establishment of the New Order. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. p.276-7.Adolf Hitler and Weinberg, Gerhard (2007) Hitler's Table Talk, 1941-1944: His Private Conversations. Enigma Books. p.356. Quoting Hitler: "For example to label the Bulgarians as Slavs is pure nonsense; originally they were Turkomans." Hitler also deemed the Bulgarians to be "Turkoman" in origin. While the Nazis were inconsistent in the implementation of their policy – for instance, mostly implementing the Final Solution while also implementing Generalplan Ost – the Democide death toll was in the range of tens of millions of victims.Rees, L (1997) The Nazis: A Warning from History, BBC Books, P126Mazower, M (2008) Hitler's Empire: How the Nazis Ruled Europe, Penguin Press P197 It is related to the concept of "life unworthy of life", a more specific term which originally referred to the severely disabled who were involuntarily euthanised in Aktion T4, and was eventually applied to the extermination of the Jews. That policy of euthanasia started officially on 1 September 1939 when Hitler signed an edict to the effect, and carbon monoxide was first used to murder disabled patients. The same gas was used in the death camps such as Treblinka, although they used engine exhaust gases to achieve the same end. In directive No. 1306 by Reich Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda from 24 October 1939, the term "Untermensch" is used in reference to Polish ethnicity and culture, as follows:
Biology classes in Nazi-era Germany schools taught about differences between the race of Nordic German " Übermenschen" and "ignoble" Jewish and Slavic "subhumans". Hitler Youth, 1922–1945: An Illustrated History by Jean-Denis Lepage, page 91 The view that Slavs were subhuman was widespread among the German masses, and chiefly applied to the Poles. It continued to find support after the war. Native Realm: A Search for Self Definition by Czeslaw Milosz, page 132
Notes
Further reading
|
|